A Faster Path to Housing, Not a Shortcut Around the Public

The new charter amendments change the land-use approval process in neighborhoods that have lagged in affordable housing production. They don’t eliminate opportunities for residents to be heard.

Photo/Alan Lexa (CTK via AP Images)

Several former chairs of the New York City Planning Commission, myself included, recently joined a Citizens Union panel to discuss how city planning changed during our respective tenures. When the conversation turned to the new charter amendments that fast-track housing approvals, some asked whether the public would becut out of the process.

I understand the worry. But it overlooks why these reforms were needed in the first place, and it underestimates the many ways New Yorkers will still have to be heard.

Start with the problem. For years, New York has asked a handful of neighborhoods to carry the load on new housing while many others added almost nothing. That imbalance was central to the case for City of Yes: in 2024, 10 community districts produced as much housing as the other 49 combined. That is no way to run a city in a housing crisis, and it isn’t fair to the neighborhoods doing the building.

In November 2025, voters approved charter amendments to change that. The most significant creates an Affordable Housing Fast Track. Beginning January 1 2027, rezonings that include permanently affordable housing in the 12 community districts producing the least of it will go through an expedited 90-day review, and the City Planning Commission will have the final say. The City Council won’t vote on them at all.

On October 1, the Department of City Planning released the list, ranking districts by how many affordable homes they added over the last five years, relative to their existing housing stock. Bay Ridge and Dyker Heights came in last. Also on the list are Staten Island’s South Shore and Mid-Island, Howard Beach, Queens Village, Bayside, Ridgewood, Corona, Borough Park, Canarsie, and the Upper East and West Sides. (I used to represent the Upper East Side in the City Council.) Together, these districts produced just 883 of the city’s 63,870 new affordable homes during that period — about 1 percent of the total.

That is why New Yorkers adopted the Fast Track. Neighborhoods that have added almost no affordable housing in five years needed more than encouragement.

The Fast Track is a real shift. Historically, the Council has had the last word on land use, and by long tradition, members deferred to whoever represented the district. In practice, that gave the local Council member something close to a veto over what got built in the neighborhood. It also made it obvious how the public could be heard: get the Council member on your side. Developers knew it too, and much of the serious negotiating, over height, community space, affordability and the rest, happened in that member’s office.

The question at the panel was how the public would continue to have a voice in these 12 districts, where the Council will no longer decide the outcome. Community boards and borough presidents will still weigh in, but their recommendations have always been advisory. Someone in Bayside or on the Upper East Side might wonder who they’re supposed to call now.

The first answer is the Planning Commission. The Commission is unique: its 13 members generally attend hearings in person, listen until everyone who wants to speak has had a chance to do so, and explain their conclusions in a written report. Now that those commissioners are the decision-makers, the Commission can and should explore ways to make itself more accessible. That could include more actively inviting written comments from the public and exploring holding Fast Track hearings in the evening, always with an option to testify remotely.

The second answer is the borough presidents. They make their own recommendations and appoint five of the Commission’s 13 members. A borough president who holds meaningful hearings and stays in touch with those appointees can create another important avenue for public input.

And Council members are still very much part of the process. They won’t vote on Fast Track projects, but they keep their standing in the community and their political weight. In Bay Ridge, which tops the Fast Track list, Council Member Kayla Santosuosso isn’t waiting for developers to show up. She has proposed rezoning a stretch of auto shops and empty storefronts to make way for housing, along with new parks, safer streets and investment in schools, and she’s bringing her neighbors into the conversation before anyone files an application. A Council member who brings a plan with community support to the Commission should be listened to, vote or no vote.

It’s clear that we’re losing something familiar. But we made these changes because too much of the work of housing New Yorkers had fallen to too few neighborhoods. Residents will still have plenty of ways to be heard, earlier in the process and, in some cases, by different people. I expect the Commission to make itself more accessible, borough presidents to step up, and Council members to keep using their political muscle. Meeting this city’s profound need for affordable housing will not come at the cost of meaningful public participation.